Reinvent Albany and NYPIRG Ask State Comptroller DiNapoli and ABO to Investigate Alleged Manipulation of Power Outage Data Related to Subway Delays


Thomas DiNapoli
Comptroller of the State of New York
110 State Street
Albany, NY 12236

Jeffrey Pearlman
Director, Authorities Budget Office
240 State Street #2076
Albany, NY 12220

January 30, 2018

Re: Request for investigation of alleged manipulation of data related to NYC subway service delays

Dear Comptroller DiNapoli and Director Pearlman,

Our groups write to request that your offices investigate four questions related to recent media reports that allege that in 2017, officials at the MTA/New York City Transit were pressured to, and did, manipulate statistics about the number of subway service delays caused by power outages, especially outages caused by Con Edison.

  • Did officials at MTA/New York City Transit manipulate, fabricate or otherwise mischaracterize statistics on the number of subway service delays caused by power outages as media reports suggest?
  • Were staff analysts at NYCT pressured by their own managers or directly or indirectly by the Governor’s Office to produce misleading or false numbers about subway problems caused by power outages so as to blame Con Edison for subway service problems?
  • Was false or misleading data generated by the NYCT used as a justification for Governor Cuomo to instruct the Public Service Commission (PSC) to order Con Edison, a private company, to perform historically unprecedented repairs on subway electrical systems that have never been Con Edison’s responsibility? These repairs have been estimated to cost Con Edison in excess of $100 million and are likely to be passed onto the general public on their power bills.
  • Has NYCT been pressured by the governor’s office, or their own senior management, to produce other misleading performance statistics? Are measures in place to prevent data from being fabricated or distorted?

At the January 25, 2018 Joint Legislative Budget Hearing on Transportation, numerous legislators raised essentially the same questions we are here, and commented that this episode has damaged public trust in MTA performance reporting.

Based on the answers to these questions, we ask your offices to recommend to the MTA measures to ensure that MTA performance reporting is solely based on facts and not on internal or external political pressure. We note that the Office of the State Comptroller has the constitutional authority to conduct compliance and performance audits and the law creating the ABO called for it to cooperate with the Comptroller’s Office.

Our request is spurred by a January 21, 2018 story by transit reporter Dan Rivoli in the NY Daily News. Rivoli’s piece, ​MTA brass pushed link between subway delays and power problems, causing Cuomo to blame Con Edison​, is based on emails between the Governor’s Office and senior managers at MTA/NYC Transit (“Transit”) and between those managers and a Transit Subway Performance Analyst.

Timeline and summary of Key Emails Reported by NY Daily News

July 25, 2017 Chief of Staff MTA/NYCT to NYCT Staff
Do you have a “higher delay number for power. Need ASAP.”

July 25, 2017 Senior Subways Analyst to Chief of Staff of MTA/NYCT
It would be possible to “expand the definition of power incidents,” but “I can’t think of a way to make ConEd/External power figures higher.”

July 26, 2017 Governor’s Press Office to Chief of Staff (MTA/NYCT)
“Do we have total real number of power-related delays over the last 12 months? Higher than the 8k.”

July 26, 2017 Chief of Staff (MTA/NYCT) to Governor’s Press
“8k is the real number of power-only incidents. However, incidents coded as signal can also be power-related.”

July 26, 2017 Governor’s Press to Chief of Staff (MTA/NYCT)
“What would be the grand total and how would you massage that language? Could we say ‘power-related issues caused more than 32,000 delays?”

July 26, 2017 Chief of Staff of MTA/NYCT to Governor’s Press Office
“I would say caused or contributed to.”

July 27, 2017 The Governor before the Association for Better New York
“Over the last 12 months, 32,000 delays because of power related issues,” “They can either be a power surge or power shortage, but 32,000 delays. The MTA doesn’t control the power, Con Edison does.”

August 9, 2017 Chief of Staff of MTA/NYCT to Senior Subways Analyst
“Can you please tell me what the 32,000 number refers to?

August 9, 2017 Senior Subways Analyst to Chief of Staff of MTA/NYCT
“ I don’t know the source of the 32,000 figure, though I remember discussing it.”

The Daily News reports that NYCT’s Senior Subway Analyst explains in a subsequent email that the real number of power related delays was 8,000, of which Con Edison was at fault for 3,422.

We also direct your attention to the list of sources listed below below.

Thank you in advance for acting on our request. Please feel free to contact John Kaehny at Reinvent Albany 917-388-9040 or ​​ with any questions.

John Kaehny
Executive Director
Reinvent Albany
info [at]

Gene Russianoff
Staff Attorney
NYPIRG/Straphangers Campaign
grussian [at]

NY Daily News​, January 21, 2018
FOILed emails between Governor and MTA/NYCT staff. problems-article-1.3769202

2nd Avenue Sagas​, January 21, 2018
Key excerpts from FOILed emails mtas-con-edison-power-play/

Politico​, November 11, 2o17
Public Service Commission orders Con Ed to do subway repairs. -work-contracts-and-costs-on-mta-electrical-repairs-118775

Governor’s Website​, July 27, 2017
Appearance before the Association for Better New York ers-remarks-association-better-new-york

“Over the last 12 months, 32,000 delays because of power related issues,” “and they can either be a power surge or power shortage, but 32,000 delays. The MTA doesn’t control the power, Con Edison does. Con Edison has a duty to safely, prudently and effectively provide electricity that powers the subway system. Con Ed is a regulated utility under the state’s Public Service Commission. April 21 after the last outage I ordered an investigation of the Con Ed infrastructure after a particularly devastating failure. The investigation goes on but PSC has already found that Con Ed must make immediate and significant improvements in this system because the reliability depends on it.”


Click here to view this post as a PDF.